My Website Investment – 6 Months Later

Lessons from investing in a website - 6 months later

After Accidentally Retiring nearly two years ago, I finally decided to put a financial plan together for the first time.

It was great to get everything down on paper and have a concrete goal. Our overarching financial goal is to:

Create enough passive income to offset all current expenses, and continue to live our current lifestyle.

Now, most of you know that first and foremost, I want to focus on simple investing.

But unfortunately for us, simple investing does not generate enough dividends to cover all of our expenses.

And because the 4% rule really isn’t safe for early retirees, combined with the fact that everything about my retirement was ill-timed and ill-planned – it was pretty clear that a big part of the withdrawal plan had to be investing in income generating assets to help reduce sequence of return risk.

And nothing, and I mean nothing, generates more income per dollar spent than a web business.

So in October 2021, after ten months of research, and one failed acquisition attempt, I took the plunge and purchased/invested an affiliate content website.

How is the website going?

So how is it all going? Good question! Thank you for asking.

Well, it has been a ride!

As I said in my initial article, buying a website is not easy – it takes a lot of time and effort to find the right fit and sift through the duds.

Running a website after you acquire it, turns out to be no different.

Web Traffic

On December 1st, 2022, Google rolled out a Product Review Update, and well the website…tanked:

I use Ahrefs to monitor Organic Keywords and Traffic for the Website.

As you can see, we had a nice steady decline in traffic.

Part of it was the Google Product Review Update, and part of it was simply the seasonal nature of the website.

Either way, it wasn’t fun for someone who took over operating the website only one month earlier.

While the website as a whole is mostly high quality content, clean and lightening fast, with a solid link profile, it clearly had some issues.

I was able to quickly identify that some of the primary issues were that we weren’t including links to multiple sellers and weren’t providing enough first hand evidence that the products were being reviewed by a real person.

So, as anyone running a business should, you figure out how to solve the problem and put together a plan to solve it.

Since the Google Product Update in December, I have been working feverishly on updating every single article on the website with multiple seller options. Then I created a brand new rating and review system, and systematically have been rolling it out since…

And fingers crossed, all of my hard work paid off:

Ahrefs again, showing recovery of the website – yay!

Google again rolled out another Product Review Update on March 22nd, and as you can see the site has recovered.

I don’t want to declare victory just yet, but so far this seems promising.

The Business Side


As you can imagine, if traffic goes down, revenue goes down in a similar fashion.

The site as a whole entered into a nuclear winter in which it went from easily covering the 20% of our household expenses that I was hoping for, to covering only 10%.

BUT, the core content for this site is based around summer activities and travel, so my hope is that we have recovered it in time for a kick ass summer season.


Expenses have been where I estimated them to be. The core costs are:

  • Google Workspace for email
  • Cloudflare for CDN/DNS
  • Domain and Hosting

Total: $75 per month

And then, we have some additional SEO and Marketing related expense that I count as “shared resources” between my two sites:

  • Ahrefs – for SEO research, keyword tracking, etc. (highly recommend)
  • Canva Pro – Easy to use graphic design
  • Frase – A great tool to research, write, and optimize SEO Content

Total: $75 per month

Finally, we have our variable costs which include paid marketing, and an independent contractor who writes content, does research, and assists with PR.

Total: ~$600 per month

While the last bucket is obviously the most expensive, it is also the bread and butter of the website.

And my goal is to continue to utilize independent contractors, and eventually ramp that up a bit, so that I can scale back my hours.

Cash Flow

Cash flow wise, the website has obviously not produced as I would like. But it is still more performant than real estate.

Even with a huge hit to the business, cash flow on a web business is typically going to be between 20-30% of the purchase price.

  • Website: with an investment of $50K, you can expect annual cash flow of between $10-$15K.
  • Real Estate: A $50K investment will generate an annual cash flow of 5-6% of the investment or $2.5-$3K.

So even with a big ding on our cash flow, you can see that we are still easily beating out what we could earn with a real estate investment -even by taking a haircut in the first six months.

Time Investment

Cash flow issues aside, the biggest investment that I’ve had to make into this website is time.

Initially I had planned on getting up to speed on the business for a few months, and then figuring out how to automate and delegate out tasks to independent contractors.

However, due to the above web traffic issues, it was pretty clear that I needed to work more “full-time” on the business. That was when I declared that I was un-retiring!

So I had to un-retire and have spent the last many months working on the business in any downtime I have.

Thankfully for you, I track my time with my time tracking spreadsheet, so we’ll have an accurate picture. Here is my hourly time investment:

  • November: 54 hours and 37 minutes
  • December: 47 hours and 50 minutes
  • January: 49 hours and 25 minutes
  • February: 39 hours and 15 minutes
  • March: 61 hours and 15 minutes
  • April: 41 hours and 15 minutes

All-in-all this averages out to about 3 hours a day.

And boy does it feel like full-time to me, but when you look at the hourly breakdown it truly isn’t.

I’ve focused a majority of my efforts around writing/editing activities, since that can singlehandedly move the needle.

But I’ve also spent a good bit of time building up the social media pages, and working on some operational activities such as negotiating new affiliate rates with affiliate partners, doing some revenue analysis, click analysis, and even a little engineering work.

Here is how it all shakes out:

Using my Time Tracking Spreadsheet, making this graphic was a breeze 🙂

Frankly, tracking my time has been a godsend in acquiring a business.

It really has helped me to focus on the core aspects that move the needle. That is why I recommend that you do it as well!

Top 9 Lessons Learned From Buying a Website

So here is all that I have learned from the last six months…

1. Diversify your traffic sources

Google algorithms can and do change on the time. This is the risk you take in purchasing a website. The best way to combat this is to diversify your traffic sources

2. It will take more hours than you think

Yep, if the previous owner claims they work on the business “3 hours a week” – bullshit!

If it was that easy, you probably wouldn’t be selling it. I’ve been working on the business 3 hours a day, not “3 hours a week.”

3. Plan for the worst case scenario

Many times when I was looking at acquiring websites, I wrote out what the worst possible scenario could be.

And damn, I just lived through it and hopefully came out stronger.

My planning helped me to mentally overcome the Google update, and lean into it.

4. Lean into it

I didn’t know TOO much about running this type of website. So I had to lean into it.

I read up on everything affiliate website I could find on the web or on Youtube.

I invested in the resources like ahrefs and Frase, and I joined FB groups to connect with other affiliate website owners.

5. Have a plan

Because I put together a solid business plan, I had thought through everything that I would attempt to do in the first six months.

While I had to throw some of that out the window and lean into the fixes for the product update, a lot of what I set out to accomplish on the marketing side worked.

Planning works – so have a plan.

6. Be open to learning new things

Really, this is a large part of why I wanted to invest in a website.

I wanted to continue to learn new things (it is one of my life mantras after all), and I wanted to sort of see where things took me. In this case, it was down an SEO rabbit hole.

7. You always learn more by doing

Look, I have a background in running websites. I have been a software engineer, and I’ve run a large company.

But it’s not everything. At the end of the day you learn by doing.

If you are afraid of taking the leap and think you don’t have enough experience. You do.

You will learn more by doing!

8. Websites aren’t passive

I knew this going into it, but running a website is an active activity.

If you are looking for passive income – look elsewhere.

9. Cash flow is the pièce de résistance

Even though cash flow was not where I wanted it to be, it was still pretty good.

In fact, better than pretty good, it was nice to have it flowing in.

Especially for an early retiree. Not having to live solely off cash reserves is a much better feeling. And hopefully it will only get better from here!


Even though it’s been a wild ride for the first six months, I am grateful that the Google Product Update happened early on in my tenure.

This really showed me where I needed to focus my time and money to recover and hopefully improve the website perminantly.

I learned a heck of a lot, and though it feels like I am working a full-time job, the reality is that I’m not.

Running this website has been a solid early retirement project, and one that I hope begins to pay more dividends in the next half of my first ownership year!

More from Accidentally Retired

AR Recommends


  1. Thanks for sharing this, very interesting. I should say I know nothing about this space – but I would be super interested in your original 6-month plan, in particular the “plan” vs “actual” if you’d be willing to share that? I think that would be super insightful.

      1. Thanks for following up! That part sounds interesting too. And I think it also makes sense to go in that order 😀 I’ll be sure to keep reading!

  2. So curious…so when you say Affiliate Website, did you choose a website whose product you’re interested in or did you just crunch numbers and buy something that made sense? I’d imagine writing for a website that you have a genuine interest in would be far easier than something that you can’t relate to.

    1. Hi Carolyn! Yes I did. One of my primary criteria in buying a website is purchasing under a topic that I have long-term interest in. While this did limit my search, it also was critical in allowing me to feel “hell yeah!” about operating it!

    1. For sure. Same goes for blogging. Getting Google traffic or social is great, but my bread and butter is email. Owned and operated wins the day!

      Though with my other business, I haven’t yet deployed an email list – that is next on the agenda after I finish optimizing and updating old content.

  3. Congrats on turning your site around after the Google update. Must’ve been a stressful time seeing your traffic drop, amazing work turning it around.

    In my view Google has just raised the bar, which in theory reduces competition so hopefully good news if you’re able to update your content. Which it looks like you have done with flying colours!

    How many articles are you adding to the site each month? Possibly a bad question if you’re writing long form long form product reviews. Just interested in your growth strategy with you highlighting how important it is to have a plan!


    1. Yeah, you are 100% right, Google is raising the bar and that is a good thing.

      Currently, we are adding about 4-5 articles to the site each month, mostly informational.

      The core of the work I have been doing is updating and enhancing older content that is ranking, but took a slight hit.

      I took a top down approach, so anything that was on Page 1 was focused on first, then Page 2, etc. Amazingly there is still so much content to be updated!

  4. Any chance you can share the site? I have enjoyed your articles on it, but would love to check it out.

    1. Hey Scott – for personal reasons and potentially disclosing my identity I have chosen not to share the site. I might share more exact details of the exact purchase price, day-to-day finances, and everything at some point, but haven’t decided on that fully yet.

      I definitely will be talking more about this again, including how to vet out and analyze sites. I have a spreadsheet I will likely share on that for anyone interested.

      1. Understand and appreciate the response and definitely the sharing. I was toying with the idea and your posts have caused me to slow down and really look hard at this (and get much smarter).

  5. That’s impressive. You’ve dedicated a lot of time and effort to be successful and it is paying off for you. Your content is remarkably good. For nonmonetized hobby bloggers like me who really have no interest in earning more money it is kind of fascinating to see what goes into doing this right.

    1. Well, I think you can’t go wrong if you are writing from the heart. But to be clear, this post was about the website I purchased, NOT Accidentally Retired. While I do have some affiliate stuff up on AR, and AR certainly does benefit from what I learn, the primary goal is not to make money either. It is to have fun and to write about things that interest me. So basically it is for me!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *